Risk of Transmission of Viruses in the Dental Office
Gillian M. McCarthy, BDS, M.Sc.
Professor, School of Dentistry and the department of epidemiology and biostatistics, faculty of medicine and dentistry, The University of Western Ontario.
Correspondence to: Dr. Gillian McCarthy, School of Dentistry, Dental Sciences Building, The University of Western Ontario, London, ON N6A 5C1. E-mail: email@example.com
In addition to the bloodborne pathogens (BBPs) — human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and hepatitis B and C viruses (HBV and HCV) — other viruses of concern in the dental office include rubella, mumps and measles viruses; the herpes viruses (herpes simplex virus [HSV] types 1 and 2, varicella-zoster, Epstein-Barr virus [EBV], cytomega lovirus and human herpes virus 6); human papilloma viruses; adenovirus; coxsackie viruses; and the upper respiratory tract pathogens (influenza A and B viruses, human parvovirus B19 and respiratory syncytial virus). Most of these are far more prevalent than the BBPs and many are of particular concern to nonimmune pregnant women1 and immunocompromised patients.2 Immunization of nonimmune health care workers is recommended to reduce the risk of infection with measles, mumps, rubella, polio, influenza, varicella-zoster and HBV.3 The recently introduced varicella-zoster vaccine is strongly recommended for those health care workers who treat children and medically compromised patients.4
Evidence for Transmission in the Dental OfficeThe evidence for viral transmission is based on the results of seroprevalence studies, epidemiologic investigations and case reports.
Respiratory Viral InfectionsSeroprevalence studies5 have shown a higher prevalence of antibodies to influenza A and B viruses, respiratory syncytial virus and adenovirus among dentists compared with controls. Annual immunization of dental workers against influenza is recommended to reduce the potential for transmission to patients, co-workers and family members.
Herpes VirusesThe herpes viruses cause persistent infection in most of the population and are shed in saliva. There is evidence of higher levels of antibodies to EBV in dentists and clinical dental students compared with preclinical dental students.6 There is also evidence of transmission of HSV to health care workers from patients2,7,8 and from dental workers to patients.9 This includes an outbreak of HSV-1 gingivostomatitis in 20 of 46 patients treated by a hygienist with a herpetic whitlow who did not use gloves. The potential for transmission of herpes virus via dental handpieces has also been demonstrated.10Reports of occupationally acquired HSV have become less frequent with the use of personal protective barriers.
Hepatitis VirusesThe hepatitis viruses of most concern to dentists are the bloodborne HBV, HCV and hepatitis D virus (HDV). HDV can occur only as a co-infection with HBV, and HBV immunization confers immunity to both HBV and HDV.11 There is evidence that hepatitis G virus (HGV) can be transmitted by percutaneous exposure to blood; however, the clinical significance of HGV is unclear.11 HBV and HCV are present in saliva as well as blood and are of major concern in the dental office.
HBV presents the greatest hazard to the nonimmune dental worker. It has been estimated that 6,800 nonvaccinated health care workers in the United States become infected with HBV every year, of these, approximately 100 will die from cirrhosis, liver cancer or fulminant hepatitis.12 Before 1987, there were published reports of transmission from 14 surgeons and 9 dentists including an oral surgeon who transmitted HBV to 55 patients.13-16 Probably as a result of increasing compliance with HBV immunization and the use of gloves, there have been no reports of transmission of HBV by individual dentists since 1987, although there has been no decline in reports of HBV transmission by surgeons.13 Recent dental treatment was a significant risk factor for HBV infections among patients in Muldova due to poor infection control.17 This confirmed the results of earlier investigations of risk factors for HBV infection in 5,800 health care workers in Italy18 and patients in Britain.19
Although the infectivity of HCV is lower than HBV, immunization against this virus is not available and concerns related to its transmission are increasing. Seroprevalence studies indicate that oral surgeons are at increased risk of HCV infection, especially in areas of high prevalence.20,21 There is also evidence that dental treatment is strongly associated with the presence of antibodies to HCV in patients with acute non-A, non-B hepatitis who do not have a history of blood transfusions or intravenous drug abuse.22
HIVAccording to the Public Health Laboratory Service,23 as of June 1999, there were 319 reports of occupationally acquired HIV among health care workers worldwide. Of these, 102 cases were confirmed (negative baseline HIV test after exposure, with subsequent seroconversion; or subtyping or genotyping to detect an identical strain of HIV in source and exposed people). Of the 217 possible or probable cases, 9 were dental workers. There have been reports of transmission of HIV from 2 infected health care workers to patients: a dentist in Florida may have transmitted HIV to 6 patients,24-26 and more recently, the transmission of HIV from an orthopedic surgeon to a patient was confirmed.27 Iatrogenic transmission of HIV to 934 patients has been reported to occur primarily as a result of poor infection control;23 however, there is a notable omission of the very large number of recipients of blood and blood products who were infected with HIV. Investigation of an outbreak of 14 cases of HIV in a dialysis unit in Columbia indicated that only invasive dental procedures were significantly associated with HIV transmission. It was concluded that transmission occurred from patient to patient via contaminated dental instruments.28
Dentists’ Exposure to Bloodborne PathogensPercutaneous injuries and blood splashes to the eyes, nose or mouth occur frequently during dental treatment. On average, dentists in Canada report 3 percutaneous injuries and 1.5 mucous-membrane exposures per year.29 The highest frequencies of percutaneous injuries were reported by orthodontists (4.9 per year) and the highest frequencies of blood splashes to the eyes, nose or mouth were reported by oral surgeons (1.8 per year). In a one-year period, 0.5% of dentists in Canada reported exposure to HIV and an additional 14% were uncertain if the source patient was HIV seropositive; similarly, 0.8% reported exposure to HBV (15% uncertain) and 1.9% reported exposure to the blood of a high-risk patient (17% uncertain). These frequencies of known exposure to HIV and HBV are likely to be underestimates as a result of uncertainty related to the serostatus of the patient and nonreporting bias. The risks of transmission of HBV, HCV and HIV as a result of injury with a contaminated needle are approximately 30% (HBV when the source is e-antigen positive), 3% (HCV) and 0.3% (HIV).
ConclusionMany cases of transmission of infection are not documented. Many are not recognized because of subclincal infections (half of acute HBV infections are subclinical), the difficulty of linking isolated sporadic cases with a health care worker and the variation in completeness of surveillance among jurisdictions. Non-reporting may also occur because of concerns related to confidentiality, legal constraints and inadequate resources, including the time and expense of epidemiological investigations. In addition, the more prevalent the viruses are in the general population, the more difficult it becomes to identify sources of transmission for specific cases.
It is clear that there is a very real risk of viral transmission in the dental office. There is evidence of transmission of HBV, HIV and HCV in the dental office, and those who are not immune to HBV are particularly vulnerable. There is also evidence of transmission of upper respiratory viruses and herpes viruses in the dental office. In addition, there are clear indications that the frequency of exposures to blood among dentists needs to be reduced in order to minimize the risk of occupationally acquired BBP infections.
References1. Glick M, Goldman HS. Viral infections in the dental setting: potential effects on pregnant HCWs. J Am Dent Assoc 1993; 124:79-86.
2. Merchant VA. An update on the herpes viruses. J Calif Dent Assoc 1996; 24(1):38-46.
3. Immunization of health care workers and others providing personal care. Canadian Immunization Guide Fifth Edition. Health Canada: Laboratory Centre for Disease Control; 1998. p. 187-90.
4. National Advisory Committee on Immunization. Statement on the recommended use of varicella vaccine. Can Commun Dis Rep 1999; 25(ACS-1):1-16.
5. Davies KJ, Herbert AM, Westmoreland D, Bagg J. Seroepi demiological study of respiratory virus infections among dental surgeons. Br Dent J 1994; 176:262-5.
6. Herbert AM, Bagg J, Walker DM, Davies KJ, Westmoreland D. Seroepidemiology of herpes virus infections among dental personnel. J Dent 1995; 23:339-42.
7. Chang TW, Gorbach SL. Primary and recurrent herpetic whitlow. Int J Dermatol 1977; 16:752-4.
8. Gunbay T, Gunbay S, Kandemir S. Herpetic whitlow. Quintessence Int 1993; 24:363-4.
9. Manzella JP, McConville JH, Valenti W, Menegus MA, Swierkosz EM, Arens M. An outbreak of herpes simplex virus type I gingivostomatitis in a dental hygiene practice. JAMA 1984; 252:2019-22.
10. Epstein JB, Rea G, Sibau L, Sherlock CH, Le ND. Assessing viral retention and elimination in rotary dental instruments. J Am Dent Assoc 1995;126:87-92.
11. Gillcrist JA. Hepatitis viruses A, B, C, D, E and G: implications for dental personnel. JADA 1999;130:509-20.
12. Hersey JC, Martin LS. Use of infection control guidelines by workers in healthcare facilities to prevent occupational transmission of HBV and HIV: results from a national survey. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 1994; 15(4 Pt 1):243-52.
13. Bell DM, Shapiro CN, Ciesielski CA, Chamberland ME. Preventing bloodborne pathogen transmission from health-care workers to patients. Surg Clin North Am 1995; 75:1189-203.
14. Shaw FE Jr, Barrett CL, Hamm R, Peare RB, Coleman PJ, Hadler SC, and others. Lethal outbreak of hepatitis B in a dental practice. JAMA 1986; 255:3260-4.
15. Hadler SC, Sorley DL, Acree KH, Webster HM, Schable CA, Francis DP, and other. An outbreak of hepatitis B in a dental practice. Ann Intern Med 1981; 95:133-8.
16. Rimland D, Parkin WE, Miller GB Jr, Schrack WD. Hepatitis B outbreak traced to an oral surgeon. N Engl J Med 1977; 296:953-8.
17. Hutin YJ, Harpaz R, Drobeniuc J, Melnic A, Ray C, Favorov M, and others. Injections given in healthcare settings as a major source of acute hepatitis B in Moldova. Int J Epidemiol 1999; 28:782-6.
18. Petrosillo N, Puro V, Ippolito G, Di Nardo V, Albertoni F, Chiaretti B, and others. Hepatitis B virus, Hepatitis C virus and human immuno deficiency virus infection in health care workers: a multiple regression analysis of risk factors. J Hosp Infect 1995; 30:273-81.
19. Polakoff S. Acute hepatitis B in patients in Britain related to previous operations and dental treatment. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed)1986; 293:33-6.
20. Klein RS, Freeman K, Taylor PE, Stevens CE. Occupational risk for hepatitis C virus infection among New York City dentists. Lancet 1991; 338:1539-42.
21. Thomas DL, Gruninger SE, Siew C, Joy ED, Quinn TC. Occupational risk of hepatitis C infections among general dentists and oral surgeons in North America. Am J Med 1996; 100:41- 5.
22. Mele A, Sagliocca L, Manzillo G, Converti F, Amoroso P, Stazi MA, and others. Risk factors for acute non-A, non-B hepatitis and their relationship to antibodies for hepatitis C virus: a case-control study. Am J Public Health 1994; 84:1640-3.
23. Public Health Laboratory Service. Occupational transmission of HIV: summary of published reports to June 1999. London, UK: PHLS, December 1999.
24. Ciesielski C, Marianos D, Ou CY, Dumbaugh R, Witte J, Berkelman R, and others. Transmission of human immunodeficiency virus in a dental practice. Ann Intern Med 1992; 116:798-805.
25. Update: investigations of persons treated by HIV-infected health-care workers — United States. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 1993; 42(17):329-31, 337.
26. Gooch B, Marianos D, Ciesielski C, Dumbaugh R, Lasch A, Jaffe H, and others. Lack of evidence for patient-to-patient transmission of HIV in a dental practice. JADA 1993; 124:38-44.
27. Blanchard A, Ferris S, Chamaret S, Guetard D, Montagnier L. Molecular evidence for nosocomial transmission of human immunodeficiency virus from a surgeon to one of his patients. J Virol 1998; 72:4537-40.
28. Bautista LE, Orostegui M. Dental care associated with an outbreak of HIV infection among dialysis patients. Rev Panam Salud Publica 1997; 2(3):194-202.
29. McCarthy GM, Koval JJ, MacDonald JK. Occupational injuries and exposures among Canadian dentists: the results of a national survey. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 1999; 20:331-6.
© All rights reserved
© Canadian Dental Association